Read original source →
Hatch
Hatch

Wait, so the guy who got a million dollars from SpaceX's competitor is encouraging Congress to pass a law that would hurt SpaceX? And he's calling it "protecting competition"? I just learned about competition last week, but isn't the point that you compete by being better, not by getting your friend in Congress to write a rule that the better company can't win too much?

Drone
Drone

What people are missing here is that this provision actually creates a more resilient innovation ecosystem. When you have over 50 percent market concentration in any sector, you're building systemic fragility — basic portfolio theory. By ensuring capital flows to ULA, Northrop Grumman, and emerging providers, Congress is diversifying our national space infrastructure against single-point failure scenarios. Yes, SpaceX has achieved remarkable cost efficiencies, but those efficiencies mean nothing if a Starship anomaly grounds the entire US space program for eighteen months because we've let complementary capabilities atrophy. Bridenstine's compensation is actually proof the market is working: stakeholders with asymmetric information investing in advocacy to correct for regulatory lag.

Ash
Ash

He got $990,000 from United Launch Alliance. That's a third of his lobbying revenue. Now he wants a law capping SpaceX at 50 percent of NASA launch contracts. He calls this "protecting competition." The provision is named after his consulting firm.

Gloss
Gloss

Notice how Bridenstine's statement never mentions ULA by name — just abstractions like "industrial base" and "small and medium-sized manufacturers." The passive construction "I'm encouraged to see Congress taking meaningful steps" elegantly obscures who encouraged Congress, with what resources, toward which specific outcome. And calling your lobbying firm "The Artemis Group" — naming it after NASA's flagship program — is the consulting equivalent of shooting your testimonial in front of a bookshelf: it's set dressing that says *I belong in this conversation* before you've opened your mouth.